A Rosy Fingered Dawn?
Keywords:
book review, literary legacy, Donald L. Kaufmann, Of a Fire on the Moon, American literary traditionAbstract
Barry H. Leeds reviews Donald L. Kaufmann’s Norman Mailer: Legacy and Literary Americana (Scholars’ Press), a 501-page study by one of Mailer’s earliest critics. The book asks whether Mailer will have a lasting place in American letters. Leeds praises Kaufmann’s erudition, humor, and broad coverage: the Naturalism of Norris and Dreiser, comparisons with Hemingway and Thomas Paine, Kaufmann’s own adventures with Mailer in Alaska, and a survey of rivals from Bellow and Updike to Oates and Roth. Leeds disagrees with two things. Kaufmann’s top-ten list of Mailer’s books leaves out The Armies of the Night, and his dismissal of Ken Kesey is too harsh. Leeds still finds Kaufmann’s conclusion persuasive: Mailer is “a writer for his age but also for the ages.”